Just read about the attack on women in a Mangalore pub for drinking alcohol and dressing indecently. I am so glad (and again thankful for readers that can be counted on the fingers of a single hand) that I am not raising my daughter there. Yes these are my thoughts on Republic Day.
This makes me imagine watching India from a distance. I imagine India as India’s map with its one billion people standing in there determined to take backward steps. There are a few that try to move forward but they lose ground and fall as people who insist on going backwards join hands. The ones that resist just get crushed. And the backward movement, its like rewinding a movie sequence. I see where it was, then I see India from 5 years back, then scenes from 10 years, 25 years and further back . I think these people who are driving this backward movement want to start from the start.
My mom never covered her head. Nor did my mother in law. My mother in law was a working Mom all her life and recently retired. They both wear sleeveless and My mother in law wears trousers comfortably. She also likes dessert wines. In my imagination, pretty soon, the movement will reach where they are standing and they will either fall or will have to join the backward surge. Then it will go further back. My grandmother outlived my granddad. May be these people will force her to burn on the pyre. And continue moving backwards.
So when did this actually start? I think it started while I was still there. When I was growing up, we watched serials such as ‘humlog’ ,’buniyaad’ and ‘udaan’ and that shaped my thinking. I still identify with the chhutki in humlog who cried that she will fail after every exam she took. That was me. That is still me. Then there was this girl in udaan who wanted to fly. That was me too. Then there was Ek kahani- a string of exotic tales by famous writers some of whom I never would have known had I not been into watching too much TV back then. And then I grew up and these serials that shaped my thinking gave way to kyonki saas bhi kabhi bahu thi and ghar ghar ki kahani. And the distinguishing characteristic of the vamp was she wanted to work, have a career and ate before the husband returned! One of my best friends’ 7 year old cousin had fallen from stairs while she was imitating one of these women and had covered her head (and her eyes). So yes those soaps do shape young minds.
Since the soaps are still on, I am glad my daughter wont be watching them.
I am an Indian. But I am also a mother. I can’t see myself joining hands with “them” and I don’t want to fall because I am holding my daugher in my arms. I will do what’s best for my child. I am sure there will be people who will tell me that I am an Indian first and that I should stay and fight these people.But I am an escapist. I would rather take the easier route. As long as I have the choice of escaping why shouldn’t I?
Will these people also tell a farmer in a drought ridden village that he should wait for the rain to come or work hard and dig a well because he was born there and his loyalty should lie there. Getting and education and moving to the city is not an option because his roots will always show, he will always be an outsider?
Or lets bring it closer home, why talk about a farmer, talk about our children. After what happened in Mangalore, wouldn’t you tell your daughter not to go in pub with her girl friends without male company to protect them? Wouldn’t you tell your daughter not to drink alcohol (without getting drunk) in a public place? Wouldn’t you tell your son and husband not to pick fights and leave with your female friends if someone tells them to?
In this scenario you either fall or end up joining hands.
I am an Indian but my daughter doesn’t have to be. Its about her. Its about me and it should be about what’s best us as a family.Yes it might not work out. Things might go really wrong in the country I finally settle in. Or who knows I might have to go back to the village because I can’t find work in the city. But that applies equally to all cases. I cannot take that unknown into consideration.
An intelligent decision has to be based on facts and the facts are that the India of my dreams is not the India of my imagination. Yes I have no loyalties. Just my selfish interests in mind. If the US fails me, I would like to move to Australia.
Trivia:
Australia’s national animal? Kangroo
Australia’s national bird? Emu
So what’s common between the two?
Both are incapable of taking backward steps! They can just move forward. Now that’s the country I want to belong to.
PS: really sleepy. have to wake up in another 4 hours. will read again tomorrow but if I am not making sense, blame it on the fact that its post midnight.
January 27, 2009 at 1:58 am
While we have a lot to be proud of on India’s Republic Day, we also have to remember that we still have a long way to go. The youth of our country are the ones who can help India reach a point where every child is educated, and every person has food to eat; where health care and clean water are available to every citizen.
Help a young person have a brighter future at GiveIndia.
http://www.giveindia.org/t-help-india-youth.aspx
January 27, 2009 at 9:41 am
You are absolutely right, your daughter deserves the best. And Australia is a great place.
And dont worry, most people if they had the option, would leave, it is not selfish, its practical, only that even when you are outside you have to keep fighting as much as you can.
January 27, 2009 at 9:51 am
You know, I am so glad I am not in India any more- after that incident- I used to live alone, I used to go out alone- it could have been me they beat up like that.
January 28, 2009 at 4:08 am
Not making sense? You brought tears to my eyes … this post says so much about what’s happening to this country.My daughter want to study abroad and I feel she’s still too young to go and stay and study so far … but this incident makes me think maybe she had better leave this country going backwards …
This was so frightening. I have been almost numb since watching this…
Absolutely loved this post…this page is open but I am not able to connect to the internet. So I will only be able to submit this comment once we are able to connect.
I made you cry? Awwwwww! Thats the nicest thing any one has ever said abt this blog. Thanks!
You must tell her that even though it feels like that post grad is not that old and she can have as much or may be more fun while studying when she is 21
And though I believe in all children living on their own for some time, I think 17 is too young too. How abt post grad. The high of new found freedom in college is gone, the returns are sooner because u enter the job market in 2 years. And why not have the best of both worlds. Go to college in India and then abroad
January 28, 2009 at 6:26 pm
You know there is one more thing I need to say. I think you are giving America and Australia too much credit. While your future in India might have been more challenging, America or Australia have let you (or me) in only because they needed you or other related reasons, not because you needed them.
America and Australia’s doors are mostly closed for a victim of child marriage in Rajasthan, a harassed lady commuter in Bangalore or a Dalit rape victim in rural India. All these ‘forward looking’ countries will do is print some news articles or say a few words here and there. But their doors will remain closed.
This is not about your personal decision but I feel its a bit unfair to blame a republic that inherited quite possibly the worst society and culture on Earth of not being able to finish the job in 60 odd years. I feel we are much further along than we were on 26th January, 1950. But as an upper caste North Indian Hindu male I might not be the best person to ask.
January 28, 2009 at 11:40 pm
Well, I think you have taken my comment in the wrong sense. My point is that America treating you better is based more on the fact that a feminist revolution has already occurred here, rather than being an intrinsic quality of the people here. You might be a second grade citizen in India but nobody here gives two hoots about that. I did not say anything about the attack in Mangalore, but since you have raised the issue ….
During the civil rights movement the governor of Louisiana prohibited black students from entering college campuses, and the national guard had to be sent in to guard the black students while in college.
Whats my point ? When one tries to brake barriers there is always resistance, and I would see this attack more in that context. This has been true in every struggle everywhere in the world. I think the u-turn you are mentioning is more the rise of a militant right-wing in post-liberalization India. The reasons for its rise are complex, and if it continues to brew it will destroy all of India in its entirety, not just harass women. But there are some signs that its on the wane.
January 29, 2009 at 7:52 am
You write well when u are sleep deprived
. I totally agree with you. I grew up in India, but my memories are made up both the place and the people. The people I grew up with have all left on their own pursuits. So if I just look at the place and its characteristics, there are very few things that I miss. I do not like the education system with everybody cramming for the JEE/CA/MBBS and anything else taken as failure. I do not like the ‘Indian culture is best’. Face it, old/longevity is not necessarily great everytime, things get rotten after some time. Totally agree with you, the incidents when I have been reminded of my color here have been too few and far between. Much more have been the incidents when I was jostled, pulled at, told I could not do something because of my gender, told I was dark. All those took place in India.
January 29, 2009 at 11:55 am
Great post and I totally agree with you. I feel India to be much more unsafer compared to here in US. My in-laws feel this too, they want us to stay here because they think anything can happen to you in India, anytime. Its so unpredictable there. There are people who are in live-in relationships(not that i believe in it, i am just mentioning it here to show that how much freedom is available to tadoay’s youth), there is so much glamour and fashion, there are independent women out there, but then there are people like Shiv Sena, who on the name of God and culture can molest girls, hit them and throw them out on streets.
January 30, 2009 at 3:24 am
Linked this brilliant post to mine on Western Culture.
January 30, 2009 at 6:34 pm
Oh, btw, sorry for spamming your blog, but I had written on exactly this kind of issue a while back, please do take a look:
http://vikramvgarg.wordpress.com/2008/11/24/indias-incomplete-modernity/?referer=sphere_related_content/
February 1, 2009 at 3:09 pm
you wrote so well and made the points so clearly. even when u are sleepy.
totally agree with u.
February 1, 2009 at 4:29 pm
[...] After reading IHM’s post, I also read Tears and Dreams’ post where she states that she is glad that she is not raising her daughter in India but in America. These posts are of course a response to the cowardly acts of a few pigeonhearted men who thought [...]